Not really the same thing as a colonial library, but the 1733 merchandise inventory for Mr. Samuel Peele (that would be the goods in his store houses, not to be confused with his household goods) lists “Stashonary &ca” including:

• 5 Gilt Bibles
• 1 plain Ditto
• 20 Testaments
• 10 Accidences
• 9 Salters
• 4 Common prayer Books
• 2 the whole duty of Man
• 8 pockett Books
• 5 primers and 8 horne Books